Audiobooks Like The Legend of Sleepy Hollow

10 audiobooks for fans of The Legend of Sleepy Hollow

1. 1

   

   H. P. Lovecraft's Book of the Supernatural

   by Stephen Jones, Henry James, Washington Irving, Edgar Allan Poe, Rudyard Kipling, Bram Stoker, Robert Louis Stevenson, Guy de Maupassant, Ambrose Bierce, Arthur Conan Doyle, Davina Porter, Steven Crossley, Bronson Pinchot

   Narrated by Davina Porter, Steven Crossley, Bronson Pinchot

   This comprehensive collection captures the same Gothic atmosphere and supernatural mystery that makes Sleepy Hollow haunting, while expanding your listening experience with additional classic tales of the unexplained from Irving and his contemporaries. The multiple skilled narrators bring fresh vocal perspectives to each story, deepening the eerie tone across the anthology's 17-hour runtime.

   ★ 3.62 ABR Score (477 ratings)

   ★ 3.68 Goodreads (339) ★ 3.99 Audible (138)

   16h 45m listening time • Released 2012

   Three stellar narrators bring genuine personality to a curated horror collection that traces the genre's DNA through its finest practitioners, making this far more than just an anthology.

   Listen Free on Audible
2. 2

   

   The Stand

   by Stephen King

   Narrated by Grover Gardner

   ★ 4.91 ABR Score (922.6K ratings)

   ★ 4.35 Goodreads (841.5K) ★ 4.69 Audible (81.1K)

   47h 47m listening time • Released 2012

   King's apocalyptic magnum opus pits good against evil across a ravaged America — sprawling, terrifying, and peopled with characters you'll never forget.

   Listen Free on Audible
3. 3

   

   Whistlin' Past the Graveyard: A Pine Deep Story

   Pine Deep

   by Jonathan Maberry

   Narrated by Ray Porter

   ★ 4.02 ABR Score (626 ratings)

   ★ 4.06 Goodreads (357) ★ 4.68 Audible (269)

   1h 6m listening time • Released 2015

   Ray Porter's gravelly, unsettling narration transforms this short horror into pure dread—he makes every whisper from the graveyard feel like a personal threat.

   Listen Free on Audible
4. 4

   

   The Trouble

   Pine Deep Trilogy

   by Jonathan Maberry

   Narrated by Ray Porter

   ★ 4.00 ABR Score (381 ratings)

   ★ 4.04 Goodreads (71) ★ 4.75 Audible (310)

   1h 16m listening time • Released 2015

   Ray Porter's narration transforms this Pine Deep sequel into a masterclass in atmospheric dread—his voice shifts between Malcolm Crow's weary resolve and something far darker, making every twist hit harder.

   Listen Free on Audible
5. 5

   

   Letter Slot

   The Shivers Collection • Book 5

   by Owen King

   Narrated by Grover Gardner

   ★ 3.81 ABR Score (8.9K ratings)

   ★ 3.84 Goodreads (8.6K) ★ 4.05 Audible (268)

   1h 14m listening time • Released 2025

   Grover Gardner's measured, almost conversational delivery transforms this Faustian bargain into something genuinely unsettling—he makes the supernatural transaction feel like a conversation with your conscience.

   Listen Free on Audible
6. 6

   

   It

   by Stephen King

   Narrated by Steven Weber

   ★ 4.90 ABR Score (1.3M ratings)

   ★ 4.24 Goodreads (1.3M) ★ 4.72 Audible (64.9K)

   44h 55m listening time • Released 2016

   Steven Weber's voice work transforms King's sprawling epic into something genuinely hypnotic—he doesn't just narrate the terror, he embodies the friendship that makes you care about it. Nearly 45 hours that feel essential.

   Listen Free on Audible
7. 7

   

   Pet Sematary

   by Stephen King

   Narrated by Michael C. Hall

   ★ 4.82 ABR Score (738.4K ratings)

   ★ 4.08 Goodreads (708.6K) ★ 4.77 Audible (29.8K)

   15h 41m listening time • Released 2018

   Listen Free on Audible
8. 8

   

   All the Stars in the Sky

   Until the End of the World • Book 3

   by Sarah Lyons Fleming

   Narrated by Julia Whelan

   ★ 4.77 ABR Score (8.7K ratings)

   ★ 4.56 Goodreads (5.0K) ★ 4.81 Audible (3.7K)

   12h 19m listening time • Released 2015

   Julia Whelan's performance captures every fracture in Cassie's determination as Fleming delivers a finale that refuses easy answers—the emotional gut-punch you've been waiting three books for.

   Listen Free on Audible
9. 9

   

   Doctor Sleep

   The Shining • Book 2

   by Stephen King

   Narrated by Will Patton

   ★ 4.75 ABR Score (340.3K ratings)

   ★ 4.13 Goodreads (300.4K) ★ 4.68 Audible (40.0K)

   18h 34m listening time • Released 2013

   Listen Free on Audible
10. 10

    

    Well Fed

    Mountain Man • Book 4

    by Keith C. Blackmore

    Narrated by R.C. Bray

    ★ 4.75 ABR Score (12.5K ratings)

    ★ 4.4 Goodreads (2.5K) ★ 4.82 Audible (10.0K)

    16h 59m listening time • Released 2015

    R.C. Bray's gravel-voiced delivery transforms this post-apocalyptic manhunt into pure survival tension, making the fourth Mountain Man book feel like a high-stakes thriller despite its bloated runtime.

    Listen Free on Audible